Would You Like a Pony? Managing Expectations

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email

A few years ago Ally Bank did a series of clever commercials with children. They all demonstrated how powerful and important expectations are and how we manage (or don’t manage) them with customers, employees and each other. The commercial with the pony captures the essence of psychological contracting.

What is Psychological Contracting?

Social psychologists who study the nature of the employment relationship refer to psychological contracting as an exchange process. Essentially, it goes like this…

“You give me the right information, in the right way, at the right time, and I’ll do the same for you…”

And it works like this…you take a job with the belief that there are mutual obligations between you and your boss, between you and the organization. This belief is based on the perception that an exchange of promises has been made. These promises are perceptual, unwritten and are not necessarily discussed, meaning that the chances that promises will be broken are pretty high.

Grounded Leaders Create Mutually Rewarding Relationships

Why does the psychological contract go awry? Let’s take an example. During the recruiting process, you heard your boss say that your company will support you and your career goals. That sounds like a promise for advancement to you.

But what your boss really meant is … if you work hard, build skills valuable to the company, if your department has the training budget and has allocated the time, you’ll get a shot at development.

There’s a lot more tied to the boss’ promise — leaving the situation wide open to broken promises. Newcomers (especially) tend to have high expectations. For many young workers, their first job gets littered with real and perceived broken promises. So what you say, from the beginning of a relationship, is remembered and taken to heart – even if only unconsciously. The promises you make, the behavior you demonstrate, how you treat employees, colleagues (even your boss), all build the first layers of this psychological contract.

When the psychological contract breaks down, either because of economic downturns or bad management, it causes anxiety, resentment and anger. This is why managing expectations (and your own expectations) is critical to being an effective leader.

In Grounded, our CEO Bob Rosen talks extensively about the need for leaders to build their social health — authenticity, mutually rewarding relationships and developing nourishing communities. Understanding the role psychological contracting plays in your ongoing leadership activities will help you tremendously.

How is your Social Health? Find out by taking the Healthy Leader Assessment – Social Health.


About the Author


Recent Post


Turning Vulnerability Into an Asset

A CEO raised by alcoholic parents develops a keen ability to observe and manage the emotions of his peers. A chronically anxious manager uses his ‘worrying’ skills to sense problems and opportunities before others do. An executive who had testicular cancer early in life uses his acquired empathy and authenticity


The Gift of Feedback

“It’s just business, nothing personal!”  How many times have you heard that before? I hate that expression. Everything is personal, especially feedback. We live in a 24X7 social world where connections are everywhere, you can’t hide from anything, and our relationships operate like social electricity. When we give or get


The Power of Resilience

Ask any business leader and he or she will tell you about the multiple times that they fell down and got up in their career. Whether it was losing a job, missing out on a promotion, screwing up with a client, or simply saying the wrong thing at the wrong



1101 Wilson Blvd. 6th Floor Arlington, VA 22209 USA


+ 1 703 351 9901


Need information here - is this new email addresses?